Type 1 and Type 2 SPDs should be distinguished by their stated test classification and discharge ratings, not by appearance or the largest number printed on a label. In the reviewed AC tables, Type 1 / Class I includes Iimp at 10/350 μs, while the Type 2 / Class II example lists In and Imax at 8/20 μs. A combined Type 1+2 device explicitly carries both classifications.
Where a class belongs in a particular distribution system is a design question. The intended installation point, protection arrangement and required duty must be defined before selecting a model. A product table can verify the proposed device’s ratings; it cannot establish the complete protection design for an unspecified building.
Compare the classification before comparing the current
Start with the EN and IEC classification rows. For the examples discussed here, the NT-25GR 3+1 table states Type 1 and Class I; NT-12.5M 320 3+NPE states Type 1+2 and Class I+II; NT-40 385 3+NPE states Type 2 and Class II. Keep the complete model notation with these rows.
The combined designation is significant. It is not created by adding together the ratings of two separate devices, nor can it be inferred merely because a table contains several current fields. The classification must be present for the specific device being proposed.
| Comparison field | NT-25GR 3+1 | NT-12.5M 320 3+NPE | NT-40 385 3+NPE |
|---|---|---|---|
| EN classification | Type 1 | Type 1+2 | Type 2 |
| IEC classification | Class I | Class I+II | Class II |
| Iimp, 10/350 μs | 25 kA | 12.5 kA | Not listed |
| In, 8/20 μs | 25 kA | 20 kA | 20 kA |
| Imax, 8/20 μs | Not listed | 65 kA | 40 kA |
| Separate N-PE Iimp | 100 kA | 50 kA | Not listed |
These are selected table entries, not complete product specifications. “Not listed” means the reviewed table does not provide that field. It does not mean zero, and it does not authorize copying a value from another model. Separate N-PE ratings are discussed below because a single row cannot describe every path.
Why 25 kA and 40 kA are not a simple ranking
The current symbol and waveform belong together. An Iimp value at 10/350 μs and an Imax value at 8/20 μs are different test statements. Comparing only their numerical magnitudes discards the conditions that make the ratings meaningful.
For example, the NT-25GR table’s Iimp 25 kA and the NT-40 table’s Imax 40 kA do not support the claim that the Type 2 device has greater capability in every respect. Nor do they establish a replacement relationship. A shortlist must compare like fields after the required classification has been identified.
In is also not a synonym for Imax. The NT-40 385 3+NPE table lists In 20 kA and Imax 40 kA. Both should remain in the purchasing specification when relevant. Reducing them to a single “40 kA SPD” description loses information and encourages comparisons with devices whose advertised current uses a different definition.
No event-count or lifetime calculation follows from these tables. They do not say that a device will survive a particular number of storms, years or incidents. Such promises should not be inferred from either class or a headline kA value.
Treat installation position as a required input
A distribution drawing should identify the intended SPD location and the duty assigned to it. Record whether the enquiry concerns an incoming assembly, another distribution board or a circuit nearer the protected equipment. Then state the required classification from the project design.
This distinction is useful when suppliers receive a request such as “an SPD for the main board.” That phrase alone leaves the supply arrangement, class, protection paths, continuous voltage and supporting protection unresolved. It is a starting description, not enough information to approve a model.
Likewise, the word “downstream” does not establish all the necessary electrical conditions. The reviewed tables provide device ratings but do not provide a universal coordination distance, a complete wiring diagram for every system or an automatic pairing rule between families.
If the project calls for Type 1 duty, shortlist devices with the relevant Type 1 or combined classification and then evaluate the remaining requirements. If it calls for Type 2 duty, check that classification and the required In/Imax fields. Where the project requires more than one protective stage, obtain an arrangement reviewed for the actual devices and installation rather than assuming that any two SPDs form a coordinated system.
Read the N-PE path separately
Three-phase configuration labels can hide important path differences if the specification is shortened too aggressively. The NT-25GR 3+1 table lists Iimp 25 kA, then separately lists N-PE Iimp 100 kA. It also gives N-PE continuous voltage and protection-level information separately.
The NT-12.5M 320 3+NPE table has its own pattern: Iimp 12.5 kA and N-PE Iimp 50 kA; In 20 kA and N-PE In 50 kA; Imax 65 kA and N-PE Imax 100 kA. Those are not interchangeable values and should not be merged into a family-wide current rating.
An enquiry should preserve the complete configuration name and identify any path-specific requirement. Do not multiply a current value by the apparent number of modules to invent a total. Do not assume a suffix has precisely the same meaning across every model without checking its connection information.
For these tables, some display headings use 3+1 while detailed model entries use 3+NPE. The practical response is to retain the detailed model notation and request the matching drawing, not to alter ratings or infer an additional configuration.
Voltage and protection level still decide suitability
Class is an early filter, not the final selection. Continuous voltage must still fit the application. The NT-25GR 3+1 table includes L-N Uc variants of 150 V, 275 V and 385 V with N-PE Uc 255 V. The combined NT-12.5M example lists Uc 320 V and N-PE Uc 255 V. The Type 2 NT-40 example lists Uc 385 V and N-PE Uc 255 V.
These distinctions prevent a class-only substitution. A combined device with the desired test classification is not automatically equivalent to a differently rated continuous-voltage variant. Confirm both requirements for the exact intended circuit.
Up must retain its path and test conditions as well. The NT-25GR table lists ≤2.0 kV and a separate ≤1.5 kV path value. The NT-12.5M example lists ≤1.5 kV. The NT-40 table lists ≤1.8 kV, plus ≤1.4 kV at 5 kA and a separate N-PE value of ≤1.5 kV. A comparison that picks only each table’s smallest number would be incomplete.
For the broader sequence from circuit requirements to a purchasing brief, use How to Choose a Surge Protective Device. It treats class, voltage, discharge duty and Up as separate decisions that must agree.
Keep supporting protection model-specific
The reviewed tables list maximum backup-fuse entries of 315 A gG for NT-25GR 3+1, 160 A for NT-12.5M 320 3+NPE and 125 A for NT-40 385 3+NPE. Preserve the descriptions as written; do not add a fuse class where the individual entry does not state one.
A maximum entry is not a universal recommendation for the installed protective device. The circuit’s protection design and the applicable installation information must establish the actual arrangement. Nor does an SPD classification alone verify compatibility with a particular backup protector.
The same caution applies to mounting and terminal data. Verify the proposed model’s drawing and installation details before including it in a panel layout. A photograph or similar housing is insufficient evidence of identical dimensions, connections or supporting protection.
A comparison sheet that can support a decision
Put the required duty in the first column and each exact proposed model in the following columns. Include classification, complete voltage variant, configuration, Iimp with waveform where present, In, Imax, path-specific Up and the supporting-protection entry. Keep unanswered fields visible.
Add a final row for unresolved project information: installation position, circuit arrangement, coordination documentation or the exact connection drawing. A comparison is useful when it reveals these gaps. It becomes misleading when missing evidence is replaced by a confident but unsupported value.
NONTIS accepts project enquiries with circuit descriptions and drawings. Start from the AC range overview and state the required duty before naming a current rating. This gives the technical discussion a clear basis without treating Type 1 and Type 2 as competing grades of the same universal device.
